We were at dinner the other night and one of the hosts said his experience with the orphans in Thailand made him a changed man. I was thinking about that the next day and remembered when there was a time in my business career when a popular business theme of “paradigm shift” appeared. This phrase was coined by T.S. Khun, a U.S. Philosopher of Science. Originally, he said it meant, “a radical change in underlying beliefs or theory”. American business redefined it as “a radical change in the way of thinking about something”.
To consider this further I wondered who in the Bible might have had a paradigm experience. The change in Peter at Pentecost came to mind. On one hand, Peter, while in the garden during Christ’s interrogation, denied knowing Him. At a later time this same Peter stood before thousands of people in Jerusalem, acknowledging who Christ was and encouraging others to do the same. Why the “radical change in underlying beliefs or theory” or “way of thinking”? Bible scholars attribute this to the anointing of the Holy Spirit at Pentecost. As a result some (Biblical scholars) may say that in order to have a paradigm shift in your life you must be anointed with the Holy Spirit, manifested by tongues of fire and loud noises.
I’m not sure this was the paradigm event. Is there another way for anointing to occur? Is “anointing” a dramatic, noisy affair or could it be the just a radical change in belief or thinking about something? The only thing my Bible says the fire and wind did was give them the ability to speak in foreign tongues. Because they demonstrated bold actions after this event, people tie the two together. There was definitely a paradigm shift in Peter. But what caused it? What caused a man to change so radically that he went from being ashamed to speak in front of a few at a bonfire, to boldly speaking before thousands and eventually giving his life?
To find an answer, I took my search back to a few days before Pentecost. Now the experience I want you to consider as Peter’s paradigm shift occurs in the writings of John, John 21:15-17. This is where Jesus has a very personal confrontation with Peter. It was important enough for John to choose it to record from among the myriad of things happening during those days.
After reading John, reconsider this question: does a radical change in a belief or way of thinking and the strong convictions which follow, come only as a result of tongues of fire, winds, etc.? Or is it the moving of the Holy Spirit in your life through an experience that causes a paradigm shift?
Next, I considered the life of Martin Luther. Did he have a paradigm shift? We don’t know every detail of Martin Luther’s life I’m sure. I have never heard of a fire anointing of the Holy Spirit in his life. I admit I am not an expert on his life, but laying down in a mud puddle in the middle of a lightning storm doesn’t qualify as an experience which changed the way he thought about religion. That only started him on the journey. What came later in life did not occur with any fanfare or accompanied by fire and wind. Yet there was a paradigm shift that shook the religious world of his day.
Is it possible that the “shift” which takes place in a person life can be deep, emotional, radical, and life changing, without the outward appearance of fire and wind, which we would attribute to the Holy Spirit acting on a person’s life? Do we want to connect the two because it makes it easier for us to understand? When we can’t see the one, we don’t want to believe the other is possible? Is it just us? Once again I leave you where I am, with questions, questions, questions.
GP